Kirt Areis E. Delovino,
William S. Lim
Publication Sub Type
Philippine Journal of Otolaryngology Head and Neck Surgery
OBJECTIVE: To design and test an improvised tracheotomy speaking valve fabricated from recycled parts of an anesthesia airway breathing circuit.
Design: Surgical Instrumentation
Setting: Tertiary Private Hospital
Subjects: Speaking valves fabricated from discarded anesthesia breathing circuit parts were pilot-tested on three patients: one with vocal fold paralysis, another with a supraglottic mass and one post hemi-laryngectomy.
RESULTS: The improvised tracheotomy speaking valve was inexpensive and relatively easy to assemble. All three patients tolerated speech well through the speaking valve and were pleased to reestablish their means of verbal communication. Maximum Phonation Time (MPT) averaged 8 seconds for all three subjects.
CONCLUSION: In our local setting, improving the quality of life of tracheotomized patients should be accessible to all, hence the value of an improvised speaking valve. It provides a more affordable means of restoring speech and because it is made from recycled materials, it is eco-friendly. Our improvised speaking valve is also a cheaper but viable alternative to more expensive commercially available ones. Clinical trials with standardized feedback questionnaires, multi-observer perceptual evaluation with a system such as the GRBAS and/or vocal acoustic measures in a speech laboratory should be made to assess long term use, efficiency and safety measures.
1. Elpern, E H, Scott, M G, Petro, L , Ries, M H. "Pulmonary aspiration in mechanically ventilated patients with tracheostomies" Chest 105(2): 563-566, February 1994
2. Suiter, D M, McCullough, G H, Powell, P W. "Effects of cuff defiation and one-way tracheostomy speaking valve placement on swallow physiology" Dysphagia 18(4): 284-292, 2003
3. Hess, D R. "Facilitating speech in the patient with a tracheostomy" Respir Care 50(4): 519-525, April 2005
4. Stachler, R J, Hamlet, S L, Chol, J , Fleming, S . "5cintigraphic quantification of aspiration reduction with the Passy-Muir valve" Laryngoscope 106(2 pt 1): 231-234, February 1996
5. Elpern, E H, Borkgren, Okonek M, Bacon, M , Gerstung, C , Skrzynski, M . "Effect of the Passy-Muir tracheostomy speaking valve on pulmonary aspiration in adults" Heart Lung 29(4): 287-293, July 2000-August 2000